Bittersweet Candy Bowl

Which would you choose? Pie or Cake?
I asked some kids in my school
So far the score is Pie: 17 Cake: 11 Undecided: 1

π

Pumpkin pie!

Cake of course.

Cake. Pie lovers are pussies.

Cake is good, so is pie, but cake is better

Pie

Cake is great man

I’ve had some really great pies, but cake wins for sure.

i pick the cake-pie!

Call me old-fashioned, but there is nothing better than a hotdog, cold beer, and a hot slice of apple pie.

Pie feels better on my cotton mouth.

Cake < Pie < Ice Cream Cake

CAKE!

(Punches a random person) CAAAAAAAAAAAKE!

But wait. I remember hearing about something called a cakepie. A cross between cake and pie…..

EDIT: Hey that hurt King.

@ Carchar - Stoner.

Hmmm. This is a topic that I never thought I would see repeated. Even though the one that I’m thinking of was originally about only cake, it turned into this discussion. *sigh*
…Pizza.

Cake, unless it’s chocolate, than pie, unless that’s anything but pumpkin, than cake.

The cake, but it also a lie

Well, the pi is irrational.

Pie for sure.

CakexPie!

Screw UndecidedxPie! Cake was friends with Pie first and Undecided just got in the way!

Pie

PIE!!!!!! in all aspects pie!!

Why have we not heard any Portal jokes yet? What is wrong with these forums?

@sammy
THE CAKE IS A LIE!!!!!
happy now?

Meh, it was too forced ¬¬

@Sammy
well i agree with you whenever cake is brought up, usally “THE CAKE IS A LIE!” is one of the frist comments.

War Heads taste like salt

Oh, my god! Guys, guess what! The cake is real this time!

In Soviet Russia YOU are the lie.

(first try)

Cake < Pie < Ice Cream Cake < ice cream pie < war heads < Cake (the band)

*high five*

The other cake topic also turned into this. Hmmm. History repeats itself…again.
I love all of Comfort Eagle especially, but everything they do is fairly fantastic. The only album I didn’t get was Motorcade of Generosity. It was just weird.
By the way, box, that was obvious, but does this mean you’re settling on one name?

PAKE

the cake is a pie

i feel dirty for saying that

NEW YORK CHEESE CAKE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Cake. nuff’ said

I hate cake with a passion and I love me some good pie… as long as isn’t any type of fruit.
(when I say cake I mean traditional cake)

Pie all the way!!!

I like pie! Hmmmmmm… … pie! PIE PIE PIE PIE PIE PIE PIE PIE PIE PIE!

I’m going with cake.

Now that I think about it… I’ve never eaten pie.
Do I deserve to live?

Pie

@Lycus: No worries. That just means you need to get better with your pickup lines.

STEAK AND ALE PIE

MMMMEAD

Magpie pie! Tastes like chicken, with a twist of random shiny things.

Both? ^_^

Both, I’d say, depending on the pie. This middle ground is quite soft, isn’t it ILB? Fancy a pie/cake picnic?

I still say pumpkin pie.